Help My Unbelief: Faith, Medicine, and the Courage to Trust Both

More great content, memes, commenting and community not available on this site.

We are also on Facebook and Instagram which have been designated terrorist organizations by the Russian government.

Anna Tumarkina

We like our recoveries clean and linear. We prefer stories where faith alone heals, or medicine alone fixes, or sheer willpower triumphs. What makes people uncomfortable is the truth: healing is often messy, slow, and shared between forces we don’t fully understand. My own experience with anxiety and depression taught me that belief—real belief—is not certainty. It is a choice made again and again in the presence of fear.

A year after my son was born, something inside me broke open. It felt as if all the pain I had ever known rose up at once and refused to let go. I couldn’t function. Depression weighed me down, while anxiety wrapped itself tightly around my thoughts—especially thoughts about my child. I was terrified to leave him alone even for minutes. Fear became my constant companion.

I went to confession expecting spiritual advice alone. Instead, the priest did something profoundly responsible: he told me to see a doctor. That single act—refusing to spiritualize an illness into silence—changed everything. I met a psychiatrist who was also a believer, someone who understood that faith and medicine are not enemies competing for the same territory.

The diagnosis was blunt: acute mixed anxiety-depressive disorder. Treatment was slow and frustrating. Medications were adjusted month after month. Some helped, others didn’t. The human mind, after all, is not a machine with interchangeable parts. What sustained me was a fragile but real hope: my intellect was intact, my brain healthy. I was ill, not lost.

Still, about once a month, panic returned like an ambush. Some blamed seasonal changes; others spoke of lunar cycles. I didn’t care why—it terrified me all the same. I developed an irrational fear of the full moon and avoided leaving the house when it rose, as though the sky itself were conspiring against me.

One evening after Communion, I walked toward a monastery for choir practice. Clouds covered the stars, but the full moon hung exposed and merciless. I panicked and rushed inside. My priest noticed my distorted, anxious face and said only one thing: “Remember—you received Communion today.”

It wasn’t magic. The fear didn’t vanish. I sang, prayed, and waited for the familiar collapse. I kept thinking, Any moment now. Now it will happen. But it didn’t. The attack hovered, threatened, and then retreated.

That simple reminder did something crucial: it interrupted the story I had been telling myself—that I was powerless, that panic was inevitable, that the moon had authority over my life. For the first time, I believed—however briefly—that fear was not sovereign.

I prayed the words from the Gospel: “Lord, I believe; help my unbelief.” That prayer matters because it tells the truth. It doesn’t pretend confidence where there is none. It asks for help not despite doubt, but because of it.

Over the next six months, the panic attacks faded and then stopped entirely. I don’t attribute this to faith alone, nor to medicine alone. I credit the cooperation of both: a priest wise enough to send me to a doctor, a doctor patient enough to find the right treatment, and a God who heals not by bypassing human means, but by working through them.

We do real harm when we frame faith and psychiatry as rivals. We harm believers who feel ashamed to seek medical help. We harm patients who think healing must look dramatic or instantaneous. And we harm ourselves when we mistake fear for fate.

Even now, when situations feel hopeless, I return to that prayer. Belief, I’ve learned, is not the absence of fear. It is the decision not to obey it.

“Lord, I believe. Help my unbelief.”

More great content, memes, commenting and community not available on this site.

We are also on Facebook and Instagram which have been designated terrorist organizations by the Russian government.